Well, the great divide between the “secular” homeschoolers and the “Christian” homeschoolers is ever widening. I put quotes around secular and Christian simply because this division is entirely artificial. Many who are lumped into the secular group are actually Christian, but apparently not Christian enough for those who refer to themselves as Christian. And the group that refers to itself as Christian, is really only a subset of Christians, for whom a more accurate title would be evangelical, fundamentalist Christians. Many who fall into the group of evangelical, fundamentalist Christian homeschoolers do not, in my opinion, behave in a very Christ-like fashion.
At first I thought I would summarize all the issues between the two groups, but I think I would have to write a book to do that. Some of it centers around controversies that don’t matter that much when you look at the big picture, such as the Homeschool Blog Awards purposely excluding blogs that didn’t live up to their worldview. Big deal. They can have their flowery little homogeneous contest. Some of it centers around the Christian dominionists at HSLDA, and their attempts to be the voice of homeschoolers, even though there are many of us they do not speak for. That also may not make a huge difference in the long run.
There is another point of contention though, that does matter. About a year and a half ago, many of us (Christian and non-Christian alike) agreed to participate in a boycott of This Old Schoolhouse magazine, and HomeschoolBlogger.com because they accepted advertising from and supported the teachings of Michael and Debi Pearl. The Pearls are the authors of the book “To Train Up a Child”, which is a supposedly biblical-based parenting manual. Except that it advocates harsh corporal punishment, to the extent that it has been described as a child-abuse manual. In February 2006, a 4-year-old child named Sean Paddock was killed by his mother, who had followed the advice in the Pearl’s book. Fast forward to the present, when some of the evangelical, fundamentalist Christian bloggers are complaining that this boycott is an attack on Christians, while other, more moderate bloggers are saying that it is at the very least an overreaction.
But I beg to differ. When it comes to abusing children, complacency is not the answer. And the owners of the Old Schoohouse and HomeschoolBlogger.com are not just complacent. They have actively supported the Pearls by using their products in promotions, and issuing a press statement defending them. I have read To Train Up a Child (you can too; the full text is posted here) and I thought it was repulsive. I described it in a post back then, but I will repeat it now:
The authors of this book advocate hitting infants that try to get up during their nap time: “to get up is to be on the firing line and get switched back downâ€. They describe hitting a child “with all the force she could possibly muster without standing for a wind-up†and hitting that same child so hard that “I heard a little karate like wheeze come from somewhere deep insideâ€. They continually talk about “conquering the child’s will†and continuing until the child is “totally brokenâ€. I simply can’t support any business that advocates that kind of behavior. And I don’t limit my opposition to just the above mentioned sites. We have on several occasions declined to purchase books from other (offline) vendors when they were also selling the Pearl’s book.
Bottom line: Yes, there is a division between the so-called Christian and secular homeschoolers. There are reasons for this, some of which are inconsequential, and others of which matter a great deal. No, I don’t care if the two sides are ever unified, and as long as the other side can’t understand our opposition to supporting child abuse, it will never happen.